It’s September so that means we all get to find out the best colleges for the coming year, thanks to US News Best College Rankings. I’m sure all those students who started at Harvard this year wish they had gone to Princeton instead since Princeton is ranked as the best college in the nation. And those at Yale must be heartbroken to be sharing the number three spot with the University of Chicago when as recently as 2010-11, Chicago was barely in the top ten. How the quality of their education and future prospects must suffer trailing Princeton and Harvard!
Yes, I have a hard time taking the rankings seriously since I can’t imagine students deciding to pick Princeton over Harvard because it’s ranked higher. If you’re actually interested in how the schools achieved their rankings, you should be aware of the following:
1. The number of full-time undergraduates at the schools that rank in the top 50 colleges in US News Best College Rankings for National Universities and National Liberal Arts Colleges represent just under 10% of all full-time undergraduates. If being in the top 10% is important to you, attending one of these schools could meet your status needs.
2. Academic reputation counts for 22.5% of the rankings on the national lists and is probably the most difficult score to change. Not that people aren’t trying. According to the methodology, “In order to reduce the impact of strategic voting by respondents, we eliminated the two highest and two lowest scores each school received before calculating the average score.” Does anyone really believe that colleges don’t care about their rankings?
Even if “presidents, provosts and deans of admissions” aren’t trying to game the system, are they really in a position to “account for intangibles at peer institutions, such as faculty dedication to teaching?” It would be a bit like asking all of the high school principals in a state to rank how good the teaching is at other high schools in the state. And they’re only to consider the intangibles, so by definition it shouldn’t be anything that can be measured.
So why include it, much less give it so much weight? How else can you ensure that the “expected” colleges show up in the top ten year after year?
3. The four-year graduation rates for the top 50 National Liberal Arts Colleges ranged from 66% to 91% and 53% to 91% for National Universities. I excluded two schools’ graduation rates. Georgia Tech as a predominately engineering schools has a lower four-year rate of 37% but its five-year rate is 75%. Northeastern doesn’t report a four-year rate, probably because it has an extensive coop program. It has a five-year rate of 79%.
There are 292 schools that aren’t in the top 50 that have a four-year graduation rate of 53% or better. Of these, 215 don’t show up in the top 100 of the national rankings. By the way, US News College Rankings uses the six-year graduation rate–how long were you planning on taking to graduate?
4. You can spend some serious cash applying to the top 50 schools. 81 have application fees of $50 or more, 47 charged $70 or more with $90 being the highest (last year’s fees). Eleven public schools are included in the group charging $70 or more. Excluding the three military academies, only two state schools charged less than $50 to apply.
5. The only public schools in the top 50 Liberal Arts Colleges rankings are the military academies.
6. As in past years, four states dominate the top 50 colleges in US News Best College Rankings: California, Massachusetts, New York, and Pennsylvania. A total of 27 National Liberal Arts Colleges and 27 National Universities are from these four states. Now this isn’t necessarily surprising since three of the states have the most total number of colleges to begin with. But there are three states with more colleges than Massachusetts, Florida, Texas, and Ohio, that have a combined total of six schools on the top 50 list.
7. It’s a good thing few students pay the full-sticker price since the average total cost of attendance for the private schools ranked in the top 50 averaged $64,331 compared to the average of $43,811 for all private schools. Public schools in the top 50 seem to have a price tag premium as well with an average of $30,206 for total cost compared to a $22,302 average for all public institutions.
Just as a FYI, US News College Rankings avoids confusing students by showing only the tuition and fees in the data table for the rankings. You have to look up the individual school and add the room and board fees back in to get the total cost of attendance. (Yes, that’s sarcasm.)
8. While the schools in the top 50 tend to be known for their generous financial aid, they aren’t exactly admitting a lot of students that really need it. Among the top 50 on the National University and National Liberal Arts College rankings, 34 schools had less than 14% of freshman receiving Pell Grants.
Why did I pick 14%? That’s the number that the Education Trust proposes as the minimum performance standard for colleges. Below 14% represents the bottom five percent of all colleges. The average for private schools in the top 50 was 14.9% compared to 41.2% for all private schools with the top 50 average for National Universities at 23.9% compared to 43.4% for all public schools.
9. It’s not as if the schools in the top 50 colleges in US News Best College Rankings are hurting for money. The average endowment per student for private schools was $427,246, over 11 times the average of $37,639 for private schools not in the top 50. Among the public schools, the top 50 average of $68,980 was seven times the average of $9,545 for all public institutions.
10. Six of the top 50 colleges in US News Best College Rankings had admission rates of 50% or better, three on the Liberal Arts Colleges list and three on the National Universities list. Another 11 had 40% or better acceptance rates. Of the 77 schools that had acceptance rates of less than 30%, 56 were in the top 50 (National or LAC). Among the 21 remaining schools, none were in the top 100 of the national rankings.
Where the Data Comes From
All of the data comes from the Integrated Postsecondary Education System (IPEDS) available for downloading as of August 2016. It’s based on four-year colleges with 500 or more full-time undergraduates. Six colleges are missing because they had fewer than 500 full-time undergraduates or do not report data to IPEDS (Hillsdale). All of the data (except the rankings) is available in the DIY College Search Spreadsheet.